Call Now Available 24/7 Free Case Review Tell us what happened

Can a Michigan auto insurer rescind a policy after a crash?

Can a Michigan auto insurer rescind a policy after a crash?

Yes. A Michigan auto insurer can seek to rescind a policy after a crash if it relied on inaccurate application information that would have changed whether it issued the policy or what terms it offered. An insurer trying to rescind a policy doesn’t determine the outcome of every coverage or injury claim.

What does policy rescission mean?

An insurer that rescinds a policy treats it as void from the start. A claim denial applies to a specific claim. Check the notice for the action the insurer took, the reason it gave and the effective date.

What counts as material misrepresentation?

In Sherman v Progressive Michigan Insurance Company, an insured person gave inaccurate answers about where she kept her vehicles and which relatives lived with her. Progressive proved that it relied on those answers and charged her less than it would have with accurate information.

The Michigan Supreme Court upheld rescission because Progressive relied on answers that changed the terms it offered and the court found no evidence that Progressive acted improperly when it issued the policy.

The insurer has to prove it relied on inaccurate application information and would have refused to issue the policy or issued it on different terms with the correct information. An honest mistake can meet that test. If rescission is disputed, the court must weigh the circumstances to decide whether undoing the policy is fair.

What should you preserve after receiving a rescission letter?

Save every version of the application and policy file and any records you have showing what the insurer or agent knew and what happened after the crash. Depending on the reason given in the notice, useful records may include:

  • the original application and every renewal, signed confirmation, update or correction
  • each declarations page and the complete insurance policy, including endorsements or other policy changes
  • emails, texts, notes, recordings and other communications with the insurer or agent
  • any record showing what an agent asked, entered, explained, received or changed
  • the rescission, cancellation, refund, reservation-of-rights and claim denial letters
  • premium invoices, payment records and refund records
  • claim forms, insurer questions and copies or proof of prior submissions
  • documents showing where each person lived, who was in the household and where each vehicle was kept
  • records showing who owned or regularly drove each vehicle and how each vehicle was used
  • the crash report, photos, videos, witness information, medical bills and medical records

Keep original electronic files when possible, including their dates and attachments. Save important messages before an account or device change makes them unavailable.

If the insurer asks for a recorded statement or written explanation, the response can affect the coverage dispute. Have the request and full policy reviewed before responding.

Why do household, residence and garaging facts matter?

The exact questions they ask and the answers you give can affect whether a rescission is approved.

Under MCL 500.3114, personal injury protection (PIP) generally covers the person named on the policy, their spouse and relatives of either who have their permanent home in the same household. PIP can help pay medical bills and replace lost wages after a crash.

An application may use different terms when asking who lives with you, who drives or owns the vehicles and where the vehicles are kept. "Household member," "household resident" and "relative domiciled in the same household" do not all mean the same thing. Neither do "listed driver," "regular driver," "residence" and "garaging address." The differences between them can greatly impact whether the answers given by the insured are accurate.

If an agent helped complete the application, save written or digital records of the agent’s involvement. Those records can show whether the application was inaccurate, what information the insurer received and whether the circumstances support rescission.

Does rescission eliminate every insurance or injury claim?

No. A rescission letter doesn’t automatically wipe out every insurance or injury claim. Each claim needs a separate legal review based on the claimant, the coverage and the application information being challenged.

That review may include:

  • The challenged policy. Can the policyholder or another insured still receive benefits under that policy?
  • Other people or claimants. Rescission does not necessarily affect a passenger, resident relative, medical provider or other claimant in the same way as the applicant. In Bazzi v Sentinel Insurance Company, the Michigan Supreme Court held that an insurer is not automatically entitled to rescission against an innocent third party. A court must weigh the circumstances to decide whether rescission should affect the innocent third party’s claim.
  • Another PIP policy. Could the injured person receive PIP benefits through their own policy, a spouse’s policy or a qualifying resident relative’s policy under MCL 500.3114? The answer can change with the injured person’s role and the statutory exceptions. Michigan Legal Center’s explanation of Michigan PIP medical bills and priority provides more detail about identifying the responsible insurer.
  • The Michigan Assigned Claims Plan. An eligible person may claim PIP benefits through the plan under MCL 500.3172 when no applicable PIP coverage exists, when no coverage can be identified or when a dispute between auto insurers prevents the applicable coverage from being determined. Assigned Claims is another route to PIP benefits, not a separate type of benefit.
  • Optional coverage. Collision, uninsured motorist and underinsured motorist coverage depend on the full policy language and the specific dispute. Michigan Legal Center’s explanation of Michigan uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage describes why the policy’s definitions, notice rules and deadlines matter.
  • A third-party injury claim. The injured person may have a separate bodily injury claim against an at-fault driver.

What can you do after the insurer denies the claim?

Save the complete record and don’t sign a release before a Michigan Legal Center attorney reviews the denial for you.

If the prior policy has ended, get the insurance Michigan law requires before driving. Acquiring insurance does not retroactively provide coverage for past crashes.

You can also file a consumer complaint with the Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS). Under DIFS’s consumer complaint process, the department reviews the documents, contacts the insurer or agent for a written response and checks compliance with the policy and law.

The Essential Insurance Act complaint process applies to qualifying denials or terminations of certain individual auto policies and disputes over premiums. DIFS reviews other claim disputes through its normal complaint process and determines which process applies.

A complaint does not guarantee that the insurer will restore the policy, pay the claim or reverse its decision.

Check your notice, claim and lawsuit deadlines even if you’ve filed a DIFS complaint, talked to the insurer, received a premium refund or are waiting on an investigation.

Michigan Legal Center can compare the application and renewals with the full policy, insurer letters and other evidence, then identify possible PIP and other coverage, required notices, release issues and deadlines. That review can help you avoid missing a deadline to claim benefits or signing away a claim you may still have. Contact Michigan Legal Center to discuss the specific records and claims.

Your Case Deserves a Real Evaluation — Not a Quick Dismissal.

We have taken on cases other firms turned away and recovered $300 million doing it. Call or submit today for a free, no-obligation consultation. Michigan's statute of limitations means time is a factor.