How much is my Michigan car accident case worth?
There is no set dollar amount or formula that tells you exactly how much a Michigan car accident case is worth. It depends on your injuries, how they affect your life and work, who caused the crash, what the records prove, how much insurance is available and whether you will need more medical care.
Just because you were offered a settlement doesn’t mean that your case is only worth that much. It’s a proposal asking you to drop your claim or claims for a set amount of money to avoid the risk of an unpredictable verdict or judgment delivered in a courtroom.
What does “case value” mean?
A case’s estimated value is based on the facts of the case, Michigan law, the insurance and the proof available. It doesn’t guarantee how much you can get in a settlement.
The ultimate value of a case isn’t limited by previous offers, but it can be affected by the chosen policy limits.
One crash could involve several claims.
Personal injury protection (PIP) benefits are for economic damages like medical bills, lost wages and attendant care.
A third-party claim against the at-fault party may include pain and suffering and financial losses PIP does not cover, in some cases.
An uninsured motorist (UM) or underinsured motorist (UIM) claim may help if the at-fault driver has no insurance or not enough insurance and you bought this coverage. This also applies to hit-and-runs or other cases where the at-fault driver can’t be identified.
Making multiple claims could mean multiple settlements, and accepting one offer could prevent you from proceeding with other claims. Michigan Legal Center can explain what the offer covers and what you would give up before you sign.
Why can't an average settlement tell me what my case is worth?
Averages leave out the facts that matter most. One person could have injuries that heal in a few weeks while someone in a very similar crash could end up needing surgery, miss months of work or live with permanent limits. Even similar injuries can lead to very different cases.
Online calculators have the same problem. They cannot tell whether the crash caused the injury, what care you may need, how much work you may miss or how much insurance is available.
Your records, losses and insurance all have an impact on the outcome of your case.
What can raise or lower the value of my case?
The main factors are:
- How serious are the injuries, and are they expected to heal?
- Will you need more treatment or live with lasting limits?
- How have the injuries affected your work, pay, home life and normal activities?
- Do the medical and wage records support those losses?
- Do the records clearly connect the injuries to the crash?
Under MCL 500.3135, Michigan only allows pain and suffering damages in crashes that caused death, permanent serious disfigurement or a serious impairment of body function. A serious impairment must be observable through symptoms or conditions by someone other than the injured person, involve a body function important to that person and affect their general ability to live as they did before the crash.
A prior medical condition does not automatically ruin your case, but can make it more difficult to prove the accident caused the injuries. Michigan Legal Center's guide to preexisting injuries after a Michigan car accident explains why earlier records matter.
How do fault and proof affect what my case is worth?
For a third-party claim, you need proof of who caused the crash, how the crash caused or worsened your injuries and how much you lost because of those injuries.
In a third-party claim, your recovery can be reduced by your percentage of fault. Under MCL 600.2959, someone more than 50% at fault can’t recover noneconomic damages, like pain and suffering. Economic damages may still be reduced by that person's percentage of fault.
Helpful proof may include:
- crash reports, photographs, video and witness names
- vehicle data or expert review when needed
- medical records, scans, test results and the doctor's outlook
- work restrictions and wage records
- statements and records showing how your daily life changed
A single record may not show the full extent of your injuries and losses. A stronger case has records and witnesses that tell the same clear story about the crash, the injuries and the losses.
How does insurance affect what I can recover?
Even a strong case can run into insurance limits which could reduce the total amount you can recover.
Michigan's default bodily injury liability limits are $250,000 per person and $500,000 per accident. But MCL 500.3009 allows drivers to choose lower limits of at least $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident if they complete the required form.
If your losses are more than the available insurance, Michigan Legal Center can check for UM/UIM coverage, umbrella policies, business insurance and other people or companies that may be responsible. An insurance card does not show every source of coverage. Michigan Legal Center's guide to Michigan UM/UIM coverage explains more.
How can I tell whether a settlement offer is fair?
You need more than the dollar amount to judge an offer. You need to know what it covers and what you will give up by accepting it.
Michigan Legal Center's Michigan Car Accident Settlement Center explains what affects claim value and what to review before accepting an offer.
Before you accept, ask whether:
- enough is known about your injuries, future care, work limits and recovery
- your medical records and wage records show the full loss
- the crash evidence shows who was at fault
- every possible insurance policy and responsible party has been checked
- the release clearly says which claims and future rights will end
The Michigan Judicial Institute explains that settlement agreements are binding contracts. Once you sign a settlement and release, it can be difficult to undo.
You do not have to figure this out alone. Contact Michigan Legal Center before accepting an offer or signing a release. Michigan Legal Center: the Law Offices of Christopher J. Trainor & Associates can review your records, investigate the crash, find all available insurance, separate the claims and explain what the release would end. You get the full picture before deciding whether the offer is fair.