Call Now Available 24/7 Free Case Review Tell us what happened

Comparative fault after a Michigan car accident: Can I recover?

Comparative fault after a Michigan car accident: Can I recover?

Yes. It’s possible for more than one person to be at fault for a crash, and each can be assigned a percentage of fault. Being partly at fault doesn’t prevent you from making an accident claim or determine the outcome.

If someone else was also at fault, your share of fault can reduce or bar what you recover from them. You may still qualify for personal injury protection (PIP) benefits regardless of who caused the crash.

What benefits and damages are affected by comparative fault?

Comparative fault assigns each legally responsible person a percentage based on what they did and how much their conduct contributed to the injury or damage. What effect that percentage of fault has depends on the type of claim.

  • PIP can help pay medical bills and replace some lost wages. Fault has no effect on PIP benefits, which are determined through coverage rules, policy limits and eligibility.
  • Someone from another state that doesn’t have Michigan no-fault insurance can get their economic damages such as medical bills paid through third-party claims. How much they can get from these claims is reduced by their percentage of fault in the crash.
  • A third-party claim seeks damages from someone legally responsible for part of your loss. Under MCL 500.3135, you may seek qualifying losses above applicable no-fault limits, such as medical expenses, lost income or financial support lost after a death. If you validly opted out of PIP medical coverage or were excluded from it under Michigan law, you may also seek qualifying medical and related expenses. Your share of fault can reduce those damages.
  • Noneconomic damages cover pain and suffering and other nonfinancial harm. Recovering those damages generally requires death, serious impairment of body function or permanent serious disfigurement. A serious impairment of body function affects an important body function and your general ability to live your normal life. Someone other than you must be able to observe or recognize the impairment from actual symptoms or conditions.
  • Mini-tort vehicle damage under MCL 500.3135(3)(e) and (4)(a), allows you to seek up to $3,000 for vehicle damage that insurance doesn’t cover. Your share of fault can reduce the amount you recover. If you were more than 50% at fault, you can’t recover mini-tort damages. You also can’t recover these damages if your vehicle was being driven without the required insurance when it was damaged.

For more on how Michigan assigns fault and reduces damages, see Michigan Legal Center’s comparative fault statute guide.

What changes when you are more than 50% at fault?

Being more than 50% at fault for a crash can bar some damages and reduce others. If you’re a Michigan resident and someone else is legally responsible for part of your loss, you may still recover qualifying economic damages. Under MCL 600.2959, your share of fault reduces those damages.

If you were more than 50% at fault, you can’t recover noneconomic damages. The same cutoff applies to a nonresident’s economic damages claim against a party whose vehicle had the required Michigan no-fault insurance. Under MCL 600.2955a, a separate rule can bar damages if alcohol or a controlled substance impaired your ability to function and that impairment made you 50% or more responsible for the crash that caused the injury or death.

Coverage, eligibility, injury causation, proof, limits and other no-fault requirements can still affect payment.

Who decides each driver’s percentage of fault?

An insurer may assign a percentage while evaluating a claim, but that number represents the insurer’s position, not the final percentage.

If a lawsuit requires a legal allocation of fault, MCL 600.2957 assigns that work to the jury or judge. They consider each person’s conduct and the extent to which it caused the claimed injury or damage.

Insurers might look at a ticket or crash report to help make their decision but those records can’t make the determination themselves. The official crash report required by Michigan law can’t be used in a court action. Independently admissible evidence, such as an officer’s firsthand observations or a driver’s statements, may still matter.

The full evidence may include:

  • photos or video showing vehicle movement, traffic signals, lane markings and road conditions
  • vehicle damage, resting positions, scene measurements and other physical evidence
  • witness accounts and the drivers’ earlier statements
  • available electronic data that bears on speed, braking, location or distraction

Medical records might prove that the crash caused the injuries but don’t prove who caused the crash. If the first report is incomplete or inaccurate, read Michigan Legal Center’s guide to a wrong Michigan car accident police report for more details.

What should you do if an insurer says you caused the crash?

Ask what evidence supports the percentage and which benefit or damages category the insurer is reducing or denying. Keep the insurer’s letters, the police report, photos, videos, messages, witness information, insurance papers and other records already available to you. Important evidence can disappear as video is overwritten, vehicles are repaired, online material is deleted and memories fade.

Release language also matters. A release may resolve more than the payment being discussed, so have a Michigan Legal Center attorney review exactly which claims and damages the document says it covers before signing.

Before giving another account, identify which insurer is asking and why. Michigan Legal Center’s guide to a recorded statement after a Michigan car accident explains that separate decision.

Michigan Legal Center attorneys can identify the separate no-fault and third-party claims, examine the insurer’s fault basis, preserve time-sensitive evidence and review proposed release language. Contact Michigan Legal Center before relying on the insurer’s fault assessment or signing a release that could close a separate claim.

Your Case Deserves a Real Evaluation — Not a Quick Dismissal.

We have taken on cases other firms turned away and recovered $300 million doing it. Call or submit today for a free, no-obligation consultation. Michigan's statute of limitations means time is a factor.