Call Now Available 24/7 Free Case Review Tell us what happened

Who’s at fault if you hit a stopped semi-truck in Michigan?

Who’s at fault if you hit a stopped semi-truck in Michigan?

No. You aren’t always at fault just because you hit a stopped semi-truck. Generally, if you rear-ended another vehicle, you would be presumed to be at fault under Michigan law. But that presumption can change and the semi driver might even be found at fault depending on the facts of the case.

Why was the semi stopped?

If traffic slowed or backed up and the semi stopped with it, that is a necessary traffic stop. According to the federal rule on stopped commercial vehicles, 49 CFR 392.22, necessary traffic stops like that don’t need hazard lights or other warning devices. Just because there was a backup doesn’t mean the truck driver had to set out emergency devices.

There are several other factors at play in a crash like this, including the approaching driver's speed, attention and available stopping distance, the truck's lights, the traffic ahead of it, the road and the view from the approaching lane.

Where was the truck, and could approaching drivers see it?

If a truck stops because of a breakdown, emergency or other stop, under 49 CFR 392.22, the driver must immediately activate hazard lights when the semi stops on public roads. This applies to any stop other than normal traffic stops.

Generally this requires the driver to place prescribed warning devices around the truck as soon as possible and within 10 minutes of the stop. The placement rules change on divided roads and near hills, curves or other obstructions. The federal rule usually does not require warning devices in a municipality’s business or residential district, except when vehicle lamps are required and street or highway lighting is insufficient to make the truck clearly visible from 500 feet.

What matters is why the truck stopped, where it was, how long it had been there and what warning it was required to give.

The required warning could take the form of reflective triangles or roadside flares depending on the federal equipment rule, 49 CFR 393.95(f). The lack of triangles doesn’t automatically establish a violation.

The truck's location also matters. On an ordinary highway outside a city or village, Michigan's stopping statute restricts stopping on the road when it is possible to move off it.

Is fault automatic in rear-end crashes?

No. In Michigan, there is a presumption of negligence in rear-end crashes, under MCL 257.402, which means that the driver who rear-ended the other vehicle is presumed at fault initially, but that presumption can be overturned with evidence. The evidence could point to either driver or another party being at fault depending on what it shows.

That presumption doesn’t apply if the crash took place between one hour after sunset and one hour before sunrise if they didn’t have a lighted lamp or lantern visible.

In a fault-based damages claim in Michigan, someone considered partially at fault can have the damages they recovered reduced by that same percentage. If they are more than 50% at fault, their noneconomic damages, such as pain and suffering, can be barred altogether.

Third-party claims for pain and suffering under MCL 500.3135 are only viable if they involve death, serious impairment of body function or permanent serious disfigurement. Personal injury protection (PIP) medical benefits may be available regardless of who caused the crash. For no-fault insurance questions, see the PIP medical-bill guide.

What evidence can show what happened before the crash?

Keep your dashcam file, photos taken from a safe location, witness contact information and any messages or reports that fix the time of the stop.

A lawyer can seek preservation of truck evidence and request available 911 and dispatch records, traffic or nearby camera footage, truck dashcam and location data, driver and carrier communications and breakdown, repair or tow records. The truck evidence-preservation guide explains the broader record request, while the rear-end accident guide covers the general presumption.

If you were injured, ask a truck-crash lawyer to review the stop and warning timeline promptly, especially if an insurer has already assigned you all fault, while video and truck records may still be available. Michigan Legal Center can help protect your claim by seeking the video and truck records before they are lost. You can request a review through the Contact Michigan Legal Center page.

Your Case Deserves a Real Evaluation — Not a Quick Dismissal.

We have taken on cases other firms turned away and recovered $300 million doing it. Call or submit today for a free, no-obligation consultation. Michigan's statute of limitations means time is a factor.