What Evidence Should You Save After a Slip and Fall in Michigan?
What evidence should you save right away after a Michigan slip and fall?
Having the right evidence may be the difference between a slip and fall case succeeding or failing. Knowing what to gather, when to do it and why it's important can be the determining factor in the success of your case. Evidence involved in these cases can be cleaned up, repaired, lost or forgotten quickly, so after a Michigan slip and fall you should document everything you can and contact a Michigan Legal Center attorney for help.
Start with the evidence you can preserve without trespassing, putting yourself in danger and legally have access to. You do not need to prove the whole case at the scene, just protect the details that show how the injury was caused, where it happened, who saw it, whether the property owner or business knew and what the property looked like.
A useful first checklist includes:
- photos and videos of the exact hazard
- wider photos showing the walkway, aisle, stairs, entrance, parking lot or surrounding area
- warning signs, cones, mats, barriers, lighting, drainage, snow, ice, liquid, debris or uneven flooring
- names and phone numbers of witnesses
- the name or job title of the manager, employee, landlord, security officer or property representative you spoke with
- incident-report details and whether you were given a copy of the incident report
- shoes and clothing worn during the fall
- receipts, appointment records, parking records or other proof you were at the location
- medical records, discharge papers and injury photos
- visible camera locations
- follow-up texts, emails, claim numbers or insurer letters
If you have only some of these items, preserve those. Michigan Legal Center can review what else may need to be requested before it is lost.
What photos, videos, and scene details should you document?
Take a variety of photos or videos from different angles and distances to capture the whole scene and ensure that all relevant details are shown. Helpful photos and videos may include:
- the hazard which may be a spill, ice, snow, water, mat, stair, handrail, threshold, pothole, curb, uneven surface, debris or broken flooring
- the direction the injured person was walking
- lighting, shadows, glare, blocked sightlines or poor visibility
- the absence or placement of warning signs
- nearby displays, carts, boxes, rugs, cords, merchandise or obstacles
- the exact aisle, entrance, stairwell, parking space, sidewalk panel, apartment hallway or building area
- measurements of a height difference, broken stair, gap, slope or uneven surface when it is safe to measure
- weather conditions, including snow, ice, rain, refreeze or standing water
- visible injuries as they develop
Do not disturb the hazard or place yourself in danger to get a better picture. If you cannot take photos yourself, ask someone with you to document the scene and write down who took the photos. Photos with timestamps or other methods of showing the exact time help because conditions can change.
Should you report the fall and ask for an incident report?
Yes. If your health allows it, report the incident to an employee, manager or owner of the business or property and ask them to create an incident report and ask for a copy.
If the report does not tell your side accurately, or if you are not given a copy, make your own notes while the details are fresh. Keep track of:
- who took the report
- that person's job title
- the date and time
- the exact location listed
- how the hazard was described
- whether witnesses were named
- whether an employee, manager or security person made any statements
- whether photos or videos were taken
- whether the report left out something important
Keep the report factual and straightforward. Describe the injury, how it was caused and what you saw. Do not guess how long the hazard was there, who caused it or whether anyone is at fault.
Why should you keep shoes, clothing, receipts, and medical records?
Your shoes and clothing can matter because property owners and insurers may argue that a fall was caused by something else such as footwear, water, oil, food, mud, torn fabric, lighting or distraction.
Photograph the shoes and clothing and avoid cleaning or repairing them. Keep them in a safe place and in the same condition until an attorney can review their importance.
Location records may help show that you were at the location at the time of the fall. This may require a purchase/parking receipt, appointment confirmation, text message, delivery record, photo timestamp, ride-share record or calendar entry.
Medical records matter for a different reason. They can help connect your injuries to the fall and show when symptoms were first reported. This can be important if an insurance company argues that your injuries came from a previous incident or condition. Keep emergency room papers, urgent care notes, imaging records, therapy referrals, discharge instructions, bills, work restrictions and photos of visible injuries.
What witness, employee, videos, and property records may need preservation?
Witness names can be difficult to get after a fall, especially in a private business or apartment building. If you can do so safely, collect names, phone numbers and a short note about what each person saw. A witness may have seen the hazard before the fall, heard an employee comment about it or noticed cleanup after you were hurt.
Also write down the names or descriptions of employees, managers, security officers, maintenance workers, snow-removal workers or contractors who were present. If a hazard was cleaned, fixed, removed or marked with a sign after the fall, the identity of the person who fixed it may be important to the claim.
A Michigan Legal Center attorney can help you send a preservation letter asking the property owner, business, landlord, manager, insurer or contractor to preserve evidence such as:
- surveillance videos and camera location information
- incident reports
- employee statements
- inspection logs and sweep logs
- cleanup records
- maintenance records
- repair records
- snow, salting or weather records
- prior complaints or prior fall reports
- employee schedules
- leases, contracts or records showing who controlled the area
A preservation letter does not decide liability and does not guarantee that every record will be produced. It is an early step to reduce the risk that relevant videos or documents are lost before the claim can be evaluated.
What if the hazard was cleaned, repaired, salted, moved, or changed?
Hazardous conditions being fixed, removed or changed does not automatically end a slip and fall case, but it can make other forms of evidence more important.
If the hazard changed before you could document it, write down what changed and when you noticed the change. Messages, photos, receipts, medical records and witness names may all be useful.
If any cameras captured the area before, during or after the fall, they may be used as evidence as well.
If no video exists, other evidence may still help show what happened. Photos, witness accounts, incident reports, medical records, inspection logs, cleanup records, repair history, prior complaints, lighting conditions, weather records and property control records may still show what happened.
How do Michigan fault, deadline, public-property, and apartment rules affect evidence?
Without necessary evidence, an injured person may have trouble responding to arguments from property owners and insurers. They may claim that the hazard was visible, the property owner acted reasonably, the hazard appeared too recently or the injured person shares fault.
The Michigan Supreme Court's decision in Kandil-Elsayed v. F & E Oil, Inc., 512 Mich. 95 (2023) changed how cases treat open-and-obvious hazards. A hazard being plainly visible may be relevant but it does not automatically mean the property owner is not liable. Courts now consider the open and obvious nature of a hazard as part of breach and comparative fault.
That makes evidence about visibility, lighting, warnings, path choice, footwear, weather and maintenance especially important.
Michigan comparative-fault law can also affect damages. Under MCL 600.2959, damages can be reduced by a person's percentage of comparative fault.
Timing also matters. There is a general three-year limitations period for many Michigan injury claims, with exceptions. But a filing deadline is not an evidence-preservation deadline. Videos, cleanup records, witnesses and scene conditions can disappear much earlier.
Public-property falls need fast attorney review. A fall involving a public sidewalk, road, or highway defect may involve MCL 691.1404. A fall involving a dangerous or defective public building may involve MCL 691.1406. Both statutes include 120-day notice language and specific notice contents. Do not rely on a general injury deadline if a government property, school, municipal parking area, public building or public sidewalk may be involved.
Apartment and rental-property falls can raise different evidence questions. MCL 554.139 addresses residential lease covenants involving premises, common areas, and reasonable repair. For an apartment hallway, stairwell, entrance, parking lot, laundry room, or common walkway, useful evidence may include lease terms, repair requests, complaints, maintenance records, property-management communications and proof of who controlled the area.
Michigan Legal Center handles Michigan slip and fall claims and broader premises liability claims. If your fall involved ice or snow, the weather-specific details should be reviewed separately, but the evidence checklist still applies. You can also contact Michigan Legal Center so our attorneys can review what happened, identify who controlled the property, and request preservation of videos and records.